The posterity decided to turn over the tragedy from this one special detail

Among the emperors of the Ming Dynasty (China), Zhou Yuanzhang is the character most mentioned by posterity because of his harshness. Not only Chu Nguyen Chuong, Chu Di (Minh Thanh To, the 3rd emperor of the Ming Dynasty) is also famous for many “scandalous” stories.

In it, there is a story associated with this emperor, Minh Thanh To, who ordered the execution of nearly 3,000 palace maids. This incident is also recorded in the history books of Korea. This is indeed a very barbaric act. So, what is the truth?


At that time, a concubine of Minh Thanh To named La Thi secretly had an illicit relationship with a eunuch behind the emperor’s back. After this matter was revealed, Minh Thanh To got angry. He sent people to arrest all those related to La Thi for interrogation and investigation. After the interrogation process, one of La Thi’s palace maids testified.

  Chu Di handled the tomb of 3,000 palace ladies: The posterity decided to overturn the tragedy from this particular detail - Photo 1.

Concubine La Thi had an illicit relationship with the eunuch and plotted to create treason that made Minh Thanh To ‘go mad’ and kill all the people involved. (Photo: Baidu)

It turned out that this concubine not only had many acts of ‘dirtying’ the harem, but also was quietly colluding with other elements, plotting treason. Minh Thanh To was originally an emperor who gained the throne through treason, so he was more and more wary of all those who had the same intentions as him in the past. Although this plan has not been implemented, La Thi still cannot avoid the crime of dying without a place to live.

Although this story is mentioned a lot, there are still many people who doubt the veracity of this incident. The point that makes the story more unbelievable is the detail of nearly 3,000 palace ladies. The fact that Minh Thanh To executed the palace maids may be true, but the number up to nearly 3,000 is hard to believe. According to China’s 163 news site, this story has many contradictions, leading to the skepticism of posterity.


Quote from a detail recorded in Korean history books about this story: “A row of 2,800 palace maids sitting side by side” [chờ xử tử]. Nearly 3,000 palace maidens is not a small number. Even executing them by the fastest and most common form of feudalism – beheading – required the most professional executioners.

  Chu Di handled the tomb of 3,000 palace maidens: The posterity decided to overturn the tragedy from this particular detail - Photo 2.

In the archives of Chinese history books, there is no record of Minh Thanh To killing nearly 3,000 palace maids. (Photo: Baidu)

The mausoleum is considered a torture with an incomparable level of brutality. The victim will have thousands of pieces of flesh on his body cut off, suffering extreme pain before dying. In some documents, it is common for the victim to have to endure about 3,000 knives before “being” dead.

Lang Tri is a punishment that requires extremely skilled executioners to be able to do it, because The average time it takes to kill an inmate is 3 days. Even the most experienced executioners can hardly kill nearly 3,000 palace maidens in a short time.


It is assumed that Minh Thanh To wanted to hide the stain of his own cruelty and intentionally interfered with the content written in the history books, but the records of the emperors’ atrocities The Ming Dynasty is not small. All stories related to Chu Nguyen Chuong were also recorded in detail and meticulous by the historians. So, there is no reason why they are afraid of Minh Thanh To hide this matter from posterity.


About this story, the history books of Korea mention a palace maiden named Kim Hac. Accordingly, this character is the Korean witness who witnessed the execution of the tomb of nearly 3,000 palace ladies by Minh Thanh To. However, there are contradictions between the historical records of Korea and China when writing about this character.

  Chu Di handled the tomb of 3,000 palace maidens: The posterity decided to turn over the tragedy from this special detail - Photo 3.

The record of the palace maiden as a witness between the two history books has many differences. (Photo: Baidu)

According to Korean history books, the palace maid Kim Hac returned to Korea from the Ming Dynasty during the reign of Emperor Minh Nhan Tong (the 4th emperor of the Ming Dynasty). But the book “Minh That Luc” (the chronicle of the Ming Dynasty) records that the palace lady Kim Hac stayed in China until the time of Emperor Minh Anh Tong (ie the 6th and 8th emperors of the Ming Dynasty). back to Korea.

Thus, the information of either of these two historical books may be untrue. Therefore, based only on records from Korean history books, it is not possible to determine the authenticity of the story about Minh The Tong’s death of nearly 3,000 palace maids.

Reference article from China’s 163 news site. now-20220324181118527.htm

According to Quynh Mai

Law and Readers

You are reading the article The posterity decided to turn over the tragedy from this one special detail
at – Source: – Read the original article here

Back to top button