Accused of wrongdoing in the auction and handover of properties, what does VNPT Dong Nai say?

Recently, VTC News received a complaint from a number of companies about VNPT Dong Nai showing signs of breaking the law in participating in auctions and handing over assets.

The denouncing enterprises include: Son Loc Steel Trading Co., Ltd; HD Thang Long Trading and Service Company Limited; Hieu Loc Production, Trade, Service and Transport Co., Ltd., Tuan Thinh Electrical Equipment Co., Ltd. These are 4 businesses (who are customers) interested in auctioning VNPT Dong Nai’s property lots in the years 2019 to present.

The property lots include: Used copper cable for recovery of damaged types, organized by the Dong Nai Property Auction Service Center on December 16, 2021. The liquidated copper cable lot of VNPT Dong Nai is auctioned by the Dong Nai Property Auction Service Center.

According to the Notice of Property Auction and Auction Regulations issued by the Property Auction Service Center of Dong Nai Province, the above 4 companies have purchased documents to view the property according to the bidding documents and registered. participate in the auction. However, after studying the auction regulations, it was found that VNPT Dong Nai put illegal conditions on participating in the auction and handing over assets.

“VNPT Dong Nai only allows customers who have viewed the property and registered their name on the minutes to confirm whether the auctioned asset participates in the auction without accepting any offers related to weighing, measuring, measuring. , counting, re-evaluating the value of properties put up for auction after the auction ends. Customers must sign the delivery and receipt in full before receiving the winning asset. Mr. Ngo Ngoc Hoai Son, Director of Son Loc Steel Trading Co., Ltd.

Ms. Nguyen Thi Phuong, Director of Hieu Loc Trading, Service and Transport Co., Ltd, said that the auctioned assets were actually gathered in an outdoor pile at the warehouse of VNPT Dong Nai in the Amata industrial zone. At the time of viewing the auction property there is no sealing, nor protection.

“In the case that the customer who won the auction after receiving the auctioned asset was handed over, there was a great loss in quantity. For example, in 2021, Truong Phat Non-ferrous Metals Co., Ltd., the auction winner, filed a complaint. Complaint to VNPT Dong Nai about detecting shortage of auctioned assets: There is no cable of size 0.65 as listed at auction”. Mrs. Phuong said.

Responding to PV on this issue, Mr. Nguyen Thanh Liem, Deputy Director of VNPT Dong Nai affirmed that the auctioned assets are sealed in the presence of customers and stored and managed in a warehouse, with a fence. There is 24/7 security so there can be no shortage or loss. At the same time, when handing over the property, the seal is still intact, so there is no change in the quantity and quality of the property.

“VNPT Dong Nai sells properties according to the actual condition of quantity, quality, and standard type at the warehouse, auction customers will see the property directly and according to the record of receipt of the auctioned asset, it will be considered that there are no any complaints about the current status of quantity, quality and type of property VNPT Dong Nai will hand over the property to the auction winner without weighing, measuring, measuring or re-counting the property, but still proceed with the discussion. deliver the whole lot in sealed condition”, Mr. Liem said.

According to Mr. Liem, in case the customer detects a shortage of assets handed over, VNPT is ready to cooperate to find out the cause and determine the responsibility. If there is a real shortage, the unit will make up for the quantity or reduce the amount equivalent to the shortage.