The doctoral thesis on developing badminton for civil servants in Son La city caused a stir

05/05/2022 15:02 GMT+7

In recent days, on academic forums and social networks, the cover image of the doctoral thesis “Research on solutions to develop badminton for civil servants in Son La city” by graduate student Dang Hoang Anh . The thesis is successfully defended in 2022. Most of the experts, scientists, and netizens are surprised and frustrated because the research “doesn’t help life”.

On the Thesis – Thesis page of the Ministry of Education and Training, full archive information is posted on the thesis “Research on solutions to develop badminton sport for civil servants in Son La city” by graduate student Dang Hoang Anh. . The topic of the education major was announced on December 23, 2021 at the Institute of Sports Science (General Department of Physical Education and Sports – Ministry of Culture, Sports and Tourism).

Thesis – Thesis page summarizes the research results: “Scientific and comprehensive information on the current situation of the badminton movement among civil servants and public employees in Son La city shows that there are still fundamental shortcomings in the field of badminton. Some publications limit the development of the movement such as: inadequate awareness of civil servants and public officials about the meaning of badminton practice; lack of badminton collaborators; poor socialization of badminton. efficiency; physical capacity of the contingent of civil servants and public employees is still limited.

At the same time, through the SWOT analysis, strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and challenges in developing the badminton movement among civil servants and public employees in Son La city.

During the research process, the topic selected 6 solutions to develop badminton for civil servants and officials of Son La city, including: propaganda about the meaning and role of badminton training and competition; develop badminton in the contingent of civil servants and public employees in the direction of socialization; create a source of cadres to develop the badminton movement for civil servants and public employees; perfecting the badminton competition system for civil servants and public employees; expanding forms of badminton training for civil servants and public employees; encourage, encourage and examine and evaluate the badminton movement of public employees.

On the basis of experimental sociology 5/6 solutions selected by the topic, initially showing the effectiveness after one year of application through the development criteria of badminton.

The experimental results show that all criteria show a positive growth (from 15.38% to 133.33%). At the same time, the solutions also have the effect of improving the fitness for civil servants and public employees in Son La city to achieve reliability at the necessary statistical probability threshold.

Searching by keyword on this page, up to 10 PhD students successfully defended their doctoral thesis related to the field of badminton development at training institutions across the country. In which, a number of theses have titles similar to those of graduate student Dang Hoang Anh.

The website of the Institute of Sports Science is currently inaccessible.

Assoc. Prof. Dr. Nguyen Van Tuan, Hanoi National University, assessed that the research topic is narrow in scope, not enough for a doctoral thesis, similar to reports, papers or at most a master’s thesis. doctor.

The purpose of the research is to point out the current situation, limitations and provide solutions for micro- and macro-scale improvements, which have great impacts on the community or the whole society. Meanwhile, the above topic about the development of badminton for civil servants and officials in Son La city is too small and does not contribute to society or the scientific community.

“In both academic and practical terms, the topic is not satisfactory. I don’t know why the research instructor agreed and the appraisal council approved such a topic”, Mr. Tuan emphasized. strong.

An education expert also said that the above topic was too small to carry out a doctoral thesis research project. “It can be seen that the censorship and appraisal of topics at the Institute of Sports Science are having problems. Industrial-style research topics, copying, copying, and pasting need to be removed immediately.”

Another scientist commented: “Reading the summary of the so-called ‘new’ articles of the thesis is nothing new and has no scientific content at all, so it cannot be considered a research result. It is similar to a report. The annual summary of the Department of Culture, Sports and Tourism is more, I don’t know who the thesis judging committee has and how is it evaluated?

According to vtc.vn