Detecting many mistakes at Phu Yen Department of Education

According to the conclusion No. 29 of the Inspectorate of Phu Yen province, the Provincial Department of Education and Training has made many mistakes in the payment of fuel costs for some department officials who go on a business trip outside the province, which is not in line with reality; spending on external work for the assessment of schools meeting national standards is not consistent with the number of working days; the investment in repair and renovation of works; allocating the budget with the teacher shortage allowance; setting up a 40% salary reform fund from public fees in contravention of regulations…

In particular, there are many mistakes in the purchase of teaching equipment.

Specifically, the package of supply and installation of multimedia classrooms with a cost of 30.8 billion VND is implemented in the form of open bidding. The winning unit is a company in Ayunpa town, Gia Lai province. . Checking this bidding package, the Inspector discovered that Dong Nam Consulting and Valuation Joint Stock Company, Ho Chi Minh City performed the price appraisal according to the method of comparing quotes of 3 enterprises in Binh Dinh as a basis. Determining the price of equipment for price appraisal is contrary to the provisions of Circular 126/2015/TT-BTC of the Ministry of Finance. Working with the Inspectorate of Phu Yen province, the winning company admitted that when appraising the price of this bidding package, the enterprise did not collect information, compare the offering price with the market price of equipment to make adjustments. Find the right price.

For the package of supply and installation of informatics equipment including 421 desktop computers costing nearly 3.6 billion VND, BTVALUE (Hanoi) Appraisal Joint Stock Company also relies only on quotes from 3 businesses in Vietnam. Hanoi, Thua Thien – Hue, Ho Chi Minh City as a basis for determining equipment prices for price appraisal without relying on market prices is against the law. The enterprise won the online bid for nearly 3.6 billion VND. Accordingly, each set of computers has a unit price of 8,475 million VND, while in the price bracket agreement document dated May 28, 2020 of the Phu Yen Department of Finance, a desktop computer with the equivalent configuration is only 7.93 million VND. synchronized.

In two other bidding packages for the procurement of minimum grade 1 teaching equipment, the online winning unit with the price of more than 17.2 billion VND and 10.5 billion VND had many signs of mistakes from the preparation of the invitation documents. bidding, evaluating bids, appraising and approving dossiers… However, the appraisal team of Phu Yen Department of Education and Training still assesses that the bidding documents and bid documents are in compliance and suitable Comply with the provisions of the law on bidding to issue a decision approving the bidding documents and contractor selection results.

The Inspectorate of Phu Yen province requested the Director of the Department of Education and Training of Phu Yen to organize a review of the concerned collectives and individuals, to review and correct the work of setting up a fund to dispute the salary difference of the affiliated units. Department, recover and remit to state budget 76 million dong due to improper expenditure and use of funds. At the same time, the Provincial Inspectorate carried out procedures to transfer the dossiers of the 1436 and Program 775 bidding packages to the Provincial Police to clarify errors in bidding and appraisal of prices.

Tram Tran